• Accident Fund
• Acuity
• Alfa Insurance Group
• Allstate Insurance Company
• American Modern Insurance Group
• American National Property & Casualty Company
• Amerisure Companies
• Auto-Owners Insurance Group
• Canal Insurance Group
• Central Mutual of Ohio Group
• Chubb Group
• Church Mutual Insurance Company
• Cincinnati Insurance Group
• Columbia Insurance Group
• The Commerce Group, Inc.
• Donegal Insurance Group
• Everest Reinsurance Group
• Federated Mutual Group
• Frankenmuth Financial Group
• GEICO
• Germania Insurance Group
• Grinnell Mutual Group
• Hastings Mutual Insurance Company
• IDS Property Casualty Insurance Company
• Indiana Farmers Mutual Insurance Company
• Jewelers Mutual Insurance Company
• Kentucky Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Company
• Louisiana Workers' Compensation Corporation
• Maine Employers Mutual Insurance Company
• Markel Corporation Group
• Mercury Casualty Group
• Merrimack Mutual Group
• New Jersey Manufacturers Group
• North Carolina Farm Bureau Insurance Group
• North Star Mutual Insurance Company
• Old Republic Insurance Group
• Pennsylvania Lumbermens Mutual Insurance Company
• Philadelphia Insurance Companies
• Progressive Casualty Insurance Company
• Protective Insurance Group
• RLI Insurance Group
• SECURA Insurance Companies
• Selective Insurance Company of America
• Sentry Insurance
• Tennessee Farmers Mutual Insurance Company
• United Fire & Casualty Group
• USAA Group
• West Bend Mutual
• Western National Mutual Insurance Group
• Western World Group

Note: The companies listed above rank as the top performing property-casualty insurance companies based on the Ward Group annual analysis of the insurance industry. They each have passed all safety and consistency screens and achieved superior performance over the five years analyzed (2000-2004). Companies are listed alphabetically. The primary objective is to benchmark their performance as a group with the rest of the property-casualty industry. Ward's 50 Benchmark Group comparisons are available in Ward's Results, an insurance industry financal reference source.